Drink Menu
Most Popular
Fall Macaron & Cider Pairing
Tiramisu + Cider Creek Drunkin Pumpkin, Pumpkin Spice + Black Bird Ghost Lantern, Caramel Apple + Nin Pin Apple Piesecco, Hazelnut Pear + Downeast Cider Donut
23
Cozy Caramel Apple
Pommeau + Caramel Apple Cider + Seltzer Water + Salted Caramel Macaron Garnish
*NA Available $8
12
Cider Slushie
Downeast: Cider Donut
Add a Cider donut for $3
8
Cider Flight
Flight of 4
-Your choice of any 4 of our 24 taps
15
Cider Mimosa Flight
4 Ciders Paired with Juice
This week's Flight:
-Cranberry Spice
-Green Apple Lemonade
-Harvest Moon (Pumpkin OJ)
-Apple Cider
14
Awestruck: Hometown Homicider
16oz Cans 6.8%
4 packs available for To-Go!
8
Bills' Mafia Juice
Pommeau+OJ +Punch+Seltzer+Whipped Cream
NA Available $6
10
Black Creek Cider: 750ml bottles
Choice of Black Currant, Cherry, or Jalapeño
15
BRLO Cider: Wild Berries
Apple, Cherry,& Blackberry
11.2oz Bottle 4.5%
7
Growlers To Go
32oz or 64 oz (includes growler)
- Premium Fill plus $3 (Brooklyn, Nine Pin, Redbyrd, Red Hammer, Black Creek, South Hill, & Finger Lakes)
17/24
Growler Refill
32 oz or 64 oz refill
- Premium Fill plus $3 (Black Creek, Brooklyn, Finger Lakes, Nine Pin, Red Hammer, Redbyrd, South Hill)
14/18
Draft Cider
@ Dry @@ Semi Sweet @@@ Sweet
#1: HAMBURG: Strawberry
@@ 6%
7
#2: Downeast: CIDER DONUT
@@@ 5.2%
8
#3: BLAKE'S: APPLE LANTERN (ROASTED PUMPKIN)
@@ 6.5%
8
#4: Cider Creek: Drunkin Pumpkin
@@ 5.5%
8
#5: BLACKBIRD: PREMIUM
@@ 6.5%
8
#6: APPLE BARREL: TART CHERRY
@@ 6%
9
#7: Redbyrd: King Bee
@ 9.8%
10
#8: STOWE: CIDER DONUT
@@ 5%
8
#9: Red Hammer: Chisel Jersey
@ 5.5%
9
#10: ORCHARD HILL: VERDE
@ 7.25%
8
#11: OSB: LUDATWIST
@ 6%
8
#12: BLACK CREEK: Jalapeño
@@ 8.5%
10
#13: South Hill: Prelude
@ 8.4%
10
#14: Blackbird: Ghost Lantern
Apple & Ghost Pepper
@@ 5.8%
8
#15: War Horse: Fall Spice
@@@ 7%
8
#16 STEAMPUNK: ORIGINAL
@@ 7%
8
#17 AWESTRUCK: PEACH RING
@@@ 6.8%
8
#18 Fleur de Lis: Pomme King
@@@ 5.5%
8
#19 DOWNEAST: Pumpkin
@@@ 5.1%
8
#20 LITTLE MACK: EMPIRE RED
@@@ 7%
9
#21 NINE PIN: Apple Pie-secco
@ 6.5%
9
#22 B NEKTAR: Zombie Killer
@@ 5.5%
10
#23 Donovan Orchard: Perry
@ 4.8%
8
#24 FLX: Triumph
@ 8%
10
Apple Wine
1911 EMPIRE DRY
@
Glass: 7 / Bottle: 18
1911 ROSÉ
@@
Glass: 7 / Bottle: 18
1911 HONEYCRISP
@@@
Glass: 7 / Bottle: 18
1911 BARREL AGED MCINTOSH
@@@
Glass: 7 / Bottle: 18
Beer
Resurgence: Oktoberfest Lager
12oz, 5%
5
Prison City: Mass Riot NEIPA
16oz, 6.8%
8
Thin Man: Pills Mafia Pilsner
4.9% 12oz
6
BLACK HOG BREWING: IPA
Juicy CT Style IPA
16 oz 6.2%
8
FAT ORANGE CAT: Baby Kittens IPA
Hazy NE STyle IPA
16oz 6.5%
8
SLOOP BREWING: JUICE BOMB NEIPA
16oz 6.5%
8
Resurgence: Circle the Wagons IPA
16oz 6.5%
8
*New *Grimm: BLACK CURRANT POP SOUR
16oz 5.1%
Pop Style Sour Ale with Black Currants, Vanilla, & Milk Sugar
9
Duclaw Brewing: Sour Me Oh Yeah!
Fruit Punch Sour, 5.5%
7
BIG DITCH: Cinnamon Apple Amber Ale
12oz 6.5%
7
*New Little House Brewing: Apple Cider Donut Scotch Ale
Scotch-Style Ale w/ Apple Cider Donut, Cinnamon, & Vanilla
16oz 7%
9
THIN MAN BREWING: OKTOBERFEST
16oz 6.3%
8
War Horse: From Scratch Pumpkin Pie Stout
Brewed with Cinnamon, All Spice, & Vanilla
16oz can 6.8%
8
Jack Abby: House Lager
16oz, 5.2%
7
BIG DITCH: MAKE ME WANNA STOUT
12oz, 5.2%
7
ATHLETIC BREWING: NA OKTOBERFEST
12oz, contains less than 0.5%
6
ATHLETIC BREWING: RUN WILD NA IPA
12oz, contains less than 0.5%
5
Cocktails
Mullers Mule
Pommeau, Ginger Beer, Lime Juice
10
No More Mr. Nice Pie
Pommeau, Cream Soda, Apple Cider, Lemon Juice, Cinnamon Stick
10
Cider-Rita
Pommeau, Lime Juice,Hard Cider, Strawberry, Lime, or Peach
10
POMMEAU ON THE ROCKS
8
Cider Mimosa
Choose from:
-Harvest Moon (Pumpkin OJ)
-Green Apple Lemonade
-Apple Cider
-Cranberry Spice
8
Non Alcoholic
Original Sin: White Widow (NA)
Non-Alcoholic Sparkling Blackberry w/ Apple Cider Vinegar
6
War Horse: Sparkling Hop Water
Tropical NA Seltzer
6
Soda
Pepsi, Diet Pepsi, Sprite
3
Shirley Temple
3
FLEUR De LIs: Orange Creamsicle Soda
16oz
4
FLEUR DE LIS: ROOT BEER
16oz
4
APPLE CIDER
3
Juice
Grape, Pineapple, Cran-Mango or Orange
4
Coffee
3
Loco Coffee: Cake Crusader Oat Milk Latte
4
Loco Coffee: Churro Oat Milk Latte
4
Loco Coffee: Mocha Oat Milk Latte
4
Dinner Menu
Appetizers
Kettle Corn
4
Chicken Wing Dip
Shredded Chicken + Hot Sauce + Cream Cheese + Topped with Scallions
12
Spinach Dip
Spinach + Red Peppers + Scallion + Cream Cheese + Paprika + Topped with Shredded Cheese
11
Dip Flight
Spinach Dip + Chicken Wing Dip + Queso to share
16
Pretzels
3 Soft Salted Pretzel Sticks, Served with Cider Queso, Spicy Brown Mustard, or Honey Mustard
12
Pizza Logs
Pizza Sauce + Mozzarella + Pepperoni. Served with a Side of our Tomato Sauce
12
Mullers Nachos
House-made Cider infused Queso + choice of Pork or Chicken + Red Onions + Tomatoes + Jalapeños + Shredded Colby Jack + Cotija Avo-Ranch Drizzle (Veggie Also Available)
16
Handhelds
ALL HANDHELDS SERVED WITH CHOICE OF SIDE: KETTLE CHIPS, MAC & CHEESE, TOMATO SOUP, CUCUMBER SALAD OR KETTLE CORN *TACOS SERVED WITH SIDE OF CHIPS AND SALSA*
Cali Chicken Wrap
Cider Braised Shredded Chicken + Colby Jack Cheese + Crumbly Bacon + Romaine + Tomato + Avocado Spread + Wrapped in a Flour Tortilla
15
BBQ Mac & Cheese Burrito
Pulled Pork + Cheddar + Mac and Cheese + BBQ Sauce
16
Philly Special
Chopped Steak + American Cheese + Queso + Onions + Chipotle Mayo on an Costanzo's Sub Roll
16
Pork Carnitas Sandwich
BBQ Pulled Pork + House-made Cole-slaw + Cheddar + Chipotle Mayo. Served on a Brioche Bun
16
Mafia Burrito
House-made Buffalo Wing Dip + Chicken Tenders + Buffalo Sauce + Red Onion + Blue Cheese Sauce + Cheddar. Served with Choice of Side
15
Stifler's Mom
Toasted Sour Dough + Pesto + Chicken Tenders + Mozzarella + American + Tomato
15
Buffalo Chicken Tacos (3)
Buffalo Chicken + Cheddar + Ranch + Flamin' Hot Cheeto Dust. Choice of Flour or Corn Shell. Served with Chips & Salsa
15
BBQ Pork Tacos (3)
BBQ Cider Pork + Coleslaw + Topped with House-made Spicy Chipotle Mayo. Served w/ Chips and Salsa. Choice of Flour or Corn shell
16
Black Bean Tacos (3)
Grilled Black Beans + Queso + Tomato + Onion + Cotija. Served w/ Chips and Salsa
13
Mini Grilled Cheese Flight
1 American + 1 Cheddar + 1 Gouda Mini Grilled Cheese on Toasted Sourdough
14
Pizza
GF Crust +5 Vegan Cheese +1 Extra Toppings +1
Wild Dill
Garlic Ranch + Pickles + Jalapeños + Mozzarella + Flaming' Hot Cheeto Dust + Ranch Drizzle
19
Chicken & Waffle Pizza
Garlic Ranch Sauce + Mozzarella + Cheddar + Jalapeños + Waffle Pieces + Chicken Fingers. Topped with Spicy Maple Drizzle
20
Vegan Meatball Pizza
Red Sauce + Vegan Mozzarella + Vegan Meatball + Crushed Red Pepper
20
585
Country Sweet Sauce + Red Peppers + Red Onion + Mozzarella + Chicken Tenders
19
Pickle
Garlic Ranch Sauce + Mozzarella + Cheddar + Dill Pickle Slices + Dill Weed
18
Pepperoni
Tomato Sauce + Mozzarella + Cup & Char Pepperoni + Parmesan
18
Buffalo Chicken
Buffalo Sauce + Cheddar + Mozzarella + Chicken Tenders + Ranch and Buffalo Drizzle
19
Prosciutto
Tomato Sauce + Mozzarella + Prosciutto + Arugula + Topped with Balsamic Glaze
19
Pesto Pollo
Pesto + Roasted Grape Tomatoes + White Onion + Adobo Chicken + Mozzarella + Garlic Aioli
19
Cheese
Blush Sauce + Parmesan + Mozzarella + Cheddar + Oregano + Black Pepper
18
Rocky
Garlic Oil + Chopped Steak + American + Cheddar + Mozzarella + White Onion
19
Big Green
Pesto + Artichokes + Spinach + Mozzarella + Grape Tomato
17
Dessert
Seasonal Macarons
Choose from: Pumpkin Spice, Caramel Apple, Hazelnut Pear, or Tiramisu
*or try all 4 for $10*
3.25
Apple Pie Logs
Apple Pie logs, Topped with Cinnamon, Sugar, & Whipped Cream
11
Sweets By The Little Brownie
Choice of Apple Crisp, Chai Snickerdoodle, or Triple Chocolate Brownie Cookie
4
My Big Fat Cookie: Stuffed Cookie Butter
6.25
My Big Fat Cookie: S'mores
6.25
My Big Fat Cookie: Red Velvet
6.25
My Big Fat Cookie: Cookies & Cream
6.25
My Big Fat Cookie: Vanilla Chai Latte
6.25
My Big Fat Cookie: Brownie Batter
6.25
My Big Fat Cookie: Chocolate Chip (GF)
6.25
Half Dozen My Big Fat Cookie
Choice of any 6 cookies
33
Brunch Menu
Available Saturday 11am-2pm & Sunday 10am-4pm
Appetizers
Kettle Corn
Original or
Specialty -
- Everything Seasoning & Bagel Chips
-Honey Mustard Onion Pretzels & Black Pepper
-Pumpkin Cheerios & Caramel Drizzle
-Butterscotch Chips & Vanilla Almond Granola
- Try all 4 in a flight!
4/8
Chicken Wing Dip
Shredded Chicken + Hot Sauce + Cream Cheese + Topped with Scallions
12
Spinach Dip
Spinach + Red Peppers + Scallion + Cream Cheese + Paprika + Topped with Shredded Cheese
11
Pretzels
3 Soft Salted Pretzel Sticks, Served with Cider Queso, Spicy Brown Mustard, or Honey Mustard
12
Pizza Logs
Pizza Sauce + Mozzarella + Pepperoni. Served with a Side of our Tomato Sauce
12
Waffles
Waffle Flight
Caramel Apple, Maple Bourbon Bacon, Fruity Pebbles, Banana Pudding
15
Banana Pudding Waffle
Belgian Waffle + Banana Pudding + Nilla Wafers + Whipped Cream + Caramel
13
Maple Bacon Bourbon
Belgian Waffle + Bacon Crumble + House Made Maple Bourbon Sauce + Whipped Cream + Powdered Sugar
15
Nutella Berry
Belgian Waffle + Nutella + Blueberries + Strawberries + Powdered Sugar + Whipped Cream
13
Chocolate Chip
Belgian Waffle + Chocolate Chips + Whipped Cream + Chocolate Drizzle + Powdered Sugar
13
Fruity Pebbles
Fruity Pebbles Waffle + Whipped Cream + Raspberry & Marshmallow Drizzle
13
Caramel Apple
Belgian Waffle + Fire Roasted Apples + Whipped Cream + Caramel Candy + Caramel Drizzle
13
Plain
Belgian Waffle + Powdered Sugar + Whipped Cream
12
Handhelds
GF Bun +2
Vegan Cheese +1
Steak and Egg Burrito
Shaved Steak + Scrambled Eggs + American Cheese + Grilled Peppers + Grilled Onions + Garlic Aioli. Served with Side of Berries and Cream
15
Cali Chicken Wrap
Cider Braised Shredded Chicken + Colby Jack Cheese + Crumbly Bacon + Romaine + Tomato + Avocado Spread + Wrapped in a Flour Tortilla
15
Breakfast Tacos
3-Spicy Chorizo + Scrambled Eggs + Red Onion + Tomato + Cotija + Avo-Ranch, on your Choice of Flour or Corn Shell. Served with Side of Berries and Cream
16
McLovin
Thick-Cut Bacon + Egg + Hash Browns + Cheddar Cheese + Garlic Aioli . Served on a Brioche Roll. Served with a side of Berries & Cream.
15
Mafia Burrito
House-made Buffalo Wing Dip + Chicken Tenders + Buffalo Sauce + Red Onion + Blue Cheese Sauce + Cheddar. Served with Choice of Side
15
It's Always Sunny at Mullers
2 Sunny Side Up Eggs + Sharp Cheddar Cheese + House-Made Sriracha Mayo + Lemon Tossed Arugula + Fresh Grilled Tomato on a Brioche Bun. Served with a side of Berries & Cream
15
Carnitas Huevos Sandwich
BBQ Pulled Pork + House-Made Coleslaw + Cheddar + Sunny Side Up Egg + Chipotle Mayo, on a Brioche Bun. Served with a Side of Chips
16
Ricky Bobby
Sausage + Eggs + Cheddar. Sandwiched on a Belgian Waffle with Spicy Maple Syrup on the Side. Served with a side of Berries & Cream
16
Veggie Melt
Eggs + Roasted Red Peppers + Spinach + Tomatoes + Cheddar Cheese. Topped with Garlic Aioli Served on a Toasted Sourdough. Served with a side of Berries & Cream
12
Avocado Toast
Avocado Spread + Sunny-Side Up Eggs + Topped with Diced Tomatoes. Served on 2 Slices of Sourdough Bread with a side of Berries & Cream
- Add 2 Slices of Bacon +3
12
Hangover
Eggs + Bacon + Sausage + Hash Browns + American Cheese + Bacon Jam on a Brioche Bun. Served with a side of Berries & Cream
16
Sarma
Beyond Sausage + Vegan Mozz + Hash Browns + Spinach + Salsa. Served on Sour Dough with a side of Berries
14
Mini Grilled Cheese Flight
1 American + 1 Cheddar + 1 Gouda Mini Grilled Cheese on Toasted Sourdough
14
Pizza
GF Crust +5
Breakfast Pizza
Garlic Ranch Sauce + Scrambled Eggs + Bacon + Mozzarella + Cheddar Cheese
19
Chicken & Waffle Pizza
Garlic Ranch Sauce + Mozzarella + Cheddar + Jalapeños + Waffle Pieces + Chicken Fingers. Topped with Spicy Maple Drizzle
20
Vegan Meatball Pizza
Red Sauce + Vegan Mozzarella + Vegan Meatball + Crushed Red Pepper
20
585
Country Sweet Sauce + Red Peppers + Red Onion + Mozzarella + Chicken Tenders
19
Pickle
Garlic Ranch Sauce + Mozzarella + Cheddar + Dill Pickle Slices + Dill Weed
18
Buffalo Chicken
Buffalo Sauce + Cheddar + Mozzarella + Chicken Tenders + Ranch and Buffalo Drizzle
19
Pepperoni
Tomato Sauce + Mozzarella + Cup & Char Pepperoni + Parmesan
18
Sides
Thick Cut Bacon
4 slices
6
Sausage
2 Patties
4
Hash Browns
4
Scrambled Eggs
4.5
Berries and Cream
3
Turkey Bacon
4 slices
5
DESSERTS
Sweets By The Little Brownie
Choice of Apple Crisp, Chai Snickerdoodle, or Triple Chocolate Brownie Cookie
4